Abbie
Abby
Abigail
Addie
Addy
Adelina
Alexi
Alexis
Alice
Ali
Allie
Ally
Alitha
Amanda
Amber
Amberlia
Ami
Amy
Anastasia
Anna
Anne
Annie
Audrey
Autumn
Audria
Bailey
Baylee
Barbara
Beatrice
Bastella
Bethany
Bridget
Brooke
Brittany
Bridges
Bianca
Brianne
Belinda
Bella
Becky
Beth
Beverly
Blanche
Bertha
Buffy
Buffie
Calli
Callie
Castella
Crina
Celena
Catherine
Courtnie
Courtney
Chloe
Cloe
Christine
Caroline
Christy
Crystal
Kristyl
Carmella
Claire
Chelsea
Chelsey
Delana
Disty
Dori
Dora
Diane
Destella
Dallas
Destiny
Destinie
Delilah
Darcy
Darcie
Daisy
Daisie
Daisey
Denessa
Dacey
Dacy
Dacey
Dasha
Diana
Diane
Daphne
Daphny
Daphnie
Dawn
Dafney
Dafnie
Daysey
Daffodil
Dakota
Dalia
Dana
Donya
Dolly
Dollie
Denma
Deona
Estella
Emma
Emily
Emmie
Emmy
Emmi
Emilie
Edna
Ebony
Ebonie
Earlene
Eve
Eva
Efrona
Elisha
Eliane
Elianna
Eleanor
Elicia
Elizbeth
Eliza
Elisa
Ella
Ellen
Eloise
Emilia
Erica
Erin
Esme
Estelle
Ethana
Felicity
Francine
Faith
Fara
Falda
Fiona
Farica
Faren
Farrah
Fawn
Fay
Floria
Frances
Fredica
Fronda
Frondy
Frondie
Felica
Felicia
Felissa
Ginger
Gabby
Gabbie
Gabbi
Gaby
Gabi
Gabrielle
Gabriella
Gail
Gale
Gala
Ganya
Garda
Genna
Gavrelle
Gayle
Garyn
Gem
Gella
Gemy
Gemma
Gene
Gena
Georgene
Georgina
Georgia
Georgette
Geraldine
Gerda
Gian
Hayley
Haley
Hailey
Haylei
Holly
Hollie
Holli
Hanna
Hannah
Halia
Halya
Hana
Hanya
Harmony
Harley
Harlie
Harmonie
Harriet
Harrie
Harry
Hayden
Heather
Hazel
Heidi
Hellen
Helen
Helan
Helice
Helga
Hespor
Heda
Hillary
Hilary
Hilarie
Hillarie
Holla
Isabell
Isabelle
Izabell
Izabelle
Izabella
Isabella
Iana
Inga
Ireland
Ircy
Iona
Iris
Iras
Ivory
Ivori
Ivorie
Izalina
Innie
Inny
Jasmine
Jazmin
Jacey
Jacie
JC
Jenna
Jetta
Jennette
Jen
Jennifer
Jennafer
Jaclyn
Jade
Janie
Jamie
Jami
Jamy
Jaynee
Jamilah
Jan
Jana
Jane
Janella
Jannessa
Janice
Jada
Jayde
Jayme
Jazz
Jazlyn
Jean
Jeana
Jedda
Jem/Jemma
Jennalyn
Jeraldina
Kadence
Kaydence
Kaya
Kay
Kaysee
Kaycee
Kasi
Kasey
Kasie
Kinley
Kinlie
Kinlei
Kimber
Kimberly
Kimberley
Kimberlia
Kahlee
Kaylee
Kayley
Kailia
Katelyn
Katelin
Kaitlin
Kaitlyn
Katy
Katie
Kaitie
Kalie
Kalee
Kaley
Karie
Kary
Karen
Karan
Karli
Karlie
Karlia
Karmyn
Kassandra
Kate
Katharine
Katherine
Kathy
Kathie
Kayla
Kelsey
Kellie
Kelly
Kendall
Kennedy
Kirstin
Kiki
KeeKee
Laney
Lanie
Lani
Lynsey
Lynsay
Linsey
Linsay
Lada
Lacy
Lacie
Lacy
Latricia
Linda
Lindy
Lindie
Lindi
Laura
Lauren
Laureen
Lassie
Lassy
Lissy
Lissie
Laury
Laurie
Leandra
Lily
Lilly
Lillie
Leola
Lucinda
Liza
Lizzie
Lizzy
Lissa
Lucille
Lucy
Lucie
Luci
Lyzabeth
Libby
Maddie
Maggie
Morgan
Misty
Monya
Madaline
Madeline
Mackie
Minnuet
Miranda
Macayla
Macinzee
Mackinzee
Mackenzie
Macy
Macie
Maci
Matilda
Mahlee
Molly
Mollie
Molli
Malory
Mallory
Malorie
Mallorie
Missy
Missie
Melissa
Malissa
Margaret
Margarat
Marcy
Marcie
Marcy
Marie
Mary
Mari
Mary
Mary
Marta
Marty
Michelle
Mary
Maxine
Nilly
Nelly
Nellie
Nestella
Nadia
Nanda
Nancy
Nanci
Nancie
Nata
Natilie
Natitly
Nokie
Neige
Nelle
Nell
Nicky
Nickie
Nicole
Nicki
Nicy
Opal
Olivia
Olly
Ollie
Olive
Ola
Olympia
Onny
Onnie
Onni
Pearl
Priscilla
Penny
Pennie
Pam
Paige
Pamela
Pamilia
Pansy
Paulina
Patricia
Patience
Peyton
Payton
Patty
Pattie
Patti
Pat
Patsy
Patsi
Patsie
Patsey
Quennie
Quenny
Qurlisha
Racheal
Rachael
Robby
Robbie
Robbi
Ronny
Ronnie
Ronni
Riley
Ronya
Ristella
Rebecca
Rolly
Rollie
Rolli
Rae
Rose
Rosann
Roseanne
Rosanne
Roseann
Stephanie
Sara
Sarah
Saige
Sada
Sabrina
Shay
Shainna
Shaniya
Selina
Salena
Samantha (Sam)
Sandy
Sandie
Sandie
Samalia
Sabrinay
Tam
Tamy
Tamara
Tami
Tamie
Tifany
Tiffany
Tifanie
Tiffanie
Takota
Tonya
Ursala
Ursla
Unstine
Ulrica
Ume
Urianna
Valory
Valorie
Veronica
Vicky
Vickie
Vicki
Velma
Valentine
Valma
Vannessa
Whitley
Witley
Whitlie
Windy
Wendy
Windie
Windi
Wandy
Wandie
Wandi
Whitney
Wilma
Xandi
Xassandra
Yalisha
Yonnie
Yonny
Yonni
Zada
Zina
Zilly
Zillie
Zillie

I typed all of these myself, so I really hope this helps you!